New York medical malpractice victims do not have an unlimited amount of time to file a lawsuit. The general deadline, known as the statute of limitations, is two years and six months from the alleged malpractice or last treatment for the same condition. But the rules are more complicated in cases involving children.
If you file too late for the applicable deadline in your case, the court may dismiss the lawsuit and deprive you or your child of any compensation. For this reason, you should seek legal counsel soon. The Long Island medical malpractice lawyers of Dell & Dean, PLLC take a closer look.
The General Deadline: Two Years and Six Months
A statute of limitations is a deadline to file a civil lawsuit. The deadline varies based on the claim. In general, for New York medical malpractice, the statute sets a deadline of two years and six months either from the date of malpractice or from the date of last treatment where there is continuous treatment for the same illness or condition.
Described in a different way, the malpractice claim generally accrues (begins to exist) when the medical malpractice occurs, but the statute of limitations may be extended under the continuous treatment doctrine when there is continuous treatment for the same condition.
Medical records can be a key piece of evidence in determining when the statute of limitations starts to run. For example, records can establish such basic facts as:
- When the allegedly negligent treatment was administered
- When a medical professional’s misdiagnosis or other error was made
- Whether treatment continued for the same condition or injury
- Whether a specific rule like the continuous treatment doctrine applies
Most malpractice victims will likely be subject to the general deadline of two years and six months. However, the issue is more complicated when children’s claims are involved and when governmental entities (e.g. a public hospital) are named as defendants.
Infancy Tolling and the Statute of Limitations in Long Island
When the victim of medical malpractice is a minor, they usually cannot file a lawsuit until reaching adulthood. For this reason, a statute of limitations may be “tolled” or temporarily paused while the victim is a minor. New York uses the term “infancy” to refer to the minor.
In a case like this, New York’s infancy tolling statute would apply. The law allows the statute of limitations to be paused while the victim is under age 18. Once the child reaches age 18, the statute of limitations starts to run and the child then has two years and six months to commence the lawsuit.
Importantly, there is a 10-year outside time limit that applies to these cases in New York. That means infancy tolling cannot last more than 10 years. This can have practical consequences depending on the child’s age. A couple of examples can help illustrate how infancy tolling and the 10-year limit work:
- A child is 16 years old when malpractice occurs: Infancy tolling would delay the statute of limitations from starting to run until the child turns 18. Then, the child has two years and six months (until about age 20½) to file. The 10-year outer limit doesn’t apply here.
- A child is 2 years old when malpractice occurs: Infancy tolling applies, but because of the 10-year rule, the child only has until about age 12 to commence the lawsuit. Because the child is still under age 18, the child’s parent or a legal guardian would file the lawsuit on their behalf.
In the first example, the child can simply commence their own lawsuit once they reach adulthood. In the second example, the child’s parent or legal guardian would file the lawsuit on the child’s behalf while they are still a minor or in “infancy.”
Birth Injuries and the Statute of Limitations in Long Island Medical Malpractice
When medical malpractice involves a birth injury, there are additional considerations. The general two year and six month deadline would typically apply because birth injury lawsuits are usually malpractice claims. However, infancy tolling and the 10-year limit also apply.
If a child’s injury occurs at birth, the child’s claim may accrue at birth. Infancy tolling may then apply, subject to the 10-year limit. A parent or legal guardian would need to commence the lawsuit while the child is a minor.
Continuous treatment for the same condition could also be relevant because the statute of limitations may be extended under the continuous treatment doctrine until the last treatment for the condition.
Differences Between the Child’s and Parent’s Claims
The examples above, particularly those involving the 2- and 16-year old and birth injuries, are the child’s own malpractice claims. The child is the victim of the malpractice, so even though a parent or guardian may file a lawsuit on their behalf, it’s still the child’s claim.
But parents can also have their own derivative claims resulting from the medical malpractice. “Derivative” means that the child was the one injured but the parents experienced losses as a result. For example, the parents may be responsible for certain medical bills to treat the child.
The difference between the two matters for purposes of the statute of limitations. The child’s claim would be subject to the above rules, but the parents’ claims are separate and generally do not receive the benefit of the child’s infancy tolling.
Claims Against the Government
One more situation worth considering for statutes of limitations purposes is when medical malpractice claims are made against a New York government entity. These often arise in the context of treatment at, for instance, a Long Island public hospital or medical clinic.
For many of these claims, the victim must as a general rule first send a Notice of Claim to the responsible government authority within 90 days after the claim arises. The lawsuit must usually commence within one year and 90 days after the cause of action accrues.
There are additional special rules when claims against government entities involve minors. The child’s infancy does not necessarily provide an extended deadline as in the above cases. These are highly fact-specific matters, so consult an attorney early if a public medical provider injured your child.
Don’t Wait to Speak to a Long Island Medical Malpractice Lawyer
The above rules and requirements demonstrate just how complicated the statute of limitations can be for medical malpractice cases involving children. Importantly, however, if you wait too long to speak with an attorney, you could permanently bar yourself or your child from any recovery.
Even if your child’s injuries are serious or the doctor or hospital was extremely negligent, missing the applicable statute of limitations is a major mistake. Waiting also risks losing valuable evidence, even if the deadline has not yet passed.
For these reasons, it’s time to speak with experienced legal counsel. Turn to Dell & Dean. We can review the facts of your case, explain your rights and options, and help you claim the compensation you or your loved one deserves. Connect with us today to get started.
