Excavation is a common construction site activity in New York. Unfortunately, there are many dangers associated with excavation. Due to the power of the equipment that’s used and the nature of construction sites, injuries resulting from excavation accidents are often catastrophic.
If you’ve been injured in an excavation accident, you will need knowledgeable legal counsel on your side. It’s time to contact the experienced New York excavation accident attorneys of Dell & Dean, PLLC. We can review the details of your case and develop a comprehensive strategy aimed at maximizing your recovery.
Types of Excavation Accidents
Unfortunately, excavation accidents occur all too frequently on construction sites. And there are various ways that workers can be seriously injured and killed. Common types of excavation accidents in New York include the following:
Trench collapses
When an excavation site’s walls cave in, workers often end up buried in the rubble and soil and suffer severe and sometimes fatal injuries. These accidents occur because protective systems, such as trench boxes or shoring, were not used or safety precautions were ignored. Workers can suffer crush injuries, traumatic brain injuries, broken bones, asphyxiation, and death.
Falls and falling materials
It is also common for workers on excavation sites to fall into trenches or excavations due to unstable ground or unprotected edges. Another common hazard is falling objects. Tools, equipment, rocks, soil, and construction materials can fall from above and strike workers below. Unsafe site conditions, lack of safety protocols, and negligence are often to blame.
Equipment malfunction
Heavy equipment such as excavators, bulldozers, loaders, and dump trucks are common at excavation sites. Equipment malfunctions and defects can cause crush injuries, amputations, traumatic brain injury, and death. On the other hand, lack of training, improper maintenance or inspection, and negligent use of the equipment can also result in catastrophic injuries.
Fires and explosions
Excavation activities on construction sites can cause fires and explosions. Sometimes, these injuries result from damage that occurs during excavation to underground gas lines and other utilities. These types of situations often involve flammable materials, which can pose risks of serious injuries to workers.
Electrocution
Electrocution is another serious type of accident. Underground utilities and exposed wires often pose significant hazards to employees on excavation sites, potentially resulting in serious harm to construction workers. Damaged equipment can also present a major hazard.
Excavation Accident Causes in New York
Understanding how your excavation accident occurred is another important step. It will be up to you, the victim, to explain how exactly you were injured. Excavation accidents have many possible causes, including:
Overloading
When the load capacity of excavating equipment or trench boxes is exceeded for an excavation project, this increases the risk of equipment failure or collapse. Overloading may be due to inadequate training or negligence, among other causes.
Lack of protective systems
The absence of appropriate sloping, shoring, or benching installation is another common cause of excavation accidents. Negligence or inadequate training may be responsible. For example, the party responsible for the protective system may have failed to recognize the trench hazard or ensure the proper method was used. Various OSHA regulations govern protective systems.
Improper equipment operation
Insufficient worker training can result in the misuse of equipment such as backhoes, excavators, and other machinery, which in turn can cause excavation accidents. Negligence, poor maintenance, and lack of suitable repair work may also account for these accidents. General OSHA equipment safety rules must be observed.
Water accumulation
Rain, groundwater, and broken pipes causing water to seep into the excavation site is a potential hazard. Water accumulation may destabilize trench walls, cause workers to slip and fall, or result in electrocution if electricity is present. There’s also the possibility of workers drowning if the water accumulation is extreme.
Excavation near structures
When excavation work is conducted near preexisting structures, it is important to follow applicable safety requirements and implement protective measures and adequate support systems. Failing to take these steps could result in trench collapses and structural damage.
Unsafe access
Unsafe access and exit points could force workers to climb unstable trench walls, use ladders that are not secured properly, or navigate poorly maintained access routes to enter or leave the excavation site. Improper site maintenance and supervision may be responsible.
Lack of proper inspections
OSHA rules generally require a competent individual to inspect excavation sites, nearby areas, and protective systems. These inspections may especially be needed after rainstorms or other events that increase hazards. Without proper inspections, dangerous conditions like unstable trench walls and water accumulation may go unnoticed.
Who May Be Held Liable for an Excavation Accident?
Liability for an excavation accident depends on several factors such as the nature of the accident, who controlled or was responsible for the work, and the relevant laws, including New York Labor Laws. Potentially responsible parties may include:
General contractors
General contractors can be held responsible when their negligence contributes to the accident. New York Labor Law §241(6) may hold contractors and property owners liable for failing to provide reasonable and adequate protection and safety at construction sites if a specific, applicable Industrial Code regulation was violated.
Subcontractors
Unsafe excavation practices could make a subcontractor responsible for a worker’s injury or death. However, whether the subcontractor is liable will depend on their role at the excavation site, their conduct leading up to the accident, and other relevant facts.
Property owners
Labor Law §241(6) may also apply to the property owner. Another possible basis for liability is New York Labor Law § 200, which codifies a common-law duty to provide workers with a reasonably safe workplace. Evidence of negligence that created a dangerous condition could render the owner liable.
Equipment manufacturers, owners, and rental companies
When unsafe, defective, improperly maintained, improperly inspected, or negligently repaired equipment causes excavation accidents, these and related parties could be held liable. As with other potentially liable parties, the specific facts will dictate whether one of these is responsible.
Utility companies
Companies responsible for electricity, gas, and other utilities at the excavation site can also be liable, depending on the facts. It will be necessary to determine what a specific utility company’s role and responsibility at the site was, along with what the company either knew or should have known leading up to the accident.
Types of Excavation Accident Injuries
Excavation accident injuries are often catastrophic. This means that they are so severe they can cause long-term or permanent disability along with immense medical, financial, and personal losses. Possible injuries may include:
- Crush injuries: Being struck by heavy objects or caught in a trench collapse can result in crush injuries. Common crush injuries include broken bones, muscular and nerve damage, and neurological injury.
- Asphyxiation and suffocation: These can occur during excavation activities due to exposure to toxic gases or lack of oxygen after striking a gas pipeline.
- Burns: Contact with hazardous materials or electrocution during excavation activities can result in severe burn injuries.
- Amputation: One particular danger of excavation activities is the possibility of a limb being caught in the moving parts of a machine, which can result in amputation.
- Head and spinal cord injuries: When an object strikes a construction worker on the head during excavation activities, serious head and spinal cord injuries can occur. Such injuries can result in brain injury, paralysis, or even death.
Potential Compensation in a New York Excavation Accident Claim
Fortunately, accident victims may be entitled to significant financial compensation for their injuries. An experienced New York excavation accident attorney can help. Workers can generally file workers’ compensation, which doesn’t require proof of negligence, and request
- Medical benefits
- Temporary total disability benefits
- Temporary partial disability benefits
- Permanent total disability benefits
- Permanent partial disability benefits
- Lost wage benefits
- Vocational rehabilitation services (when applicable)
- Death benefits for eligible dependents
- Funeral and burial expenses
However, depending on the facts of the case, an injured excavation worker may also be able to file a separate personal injury lawsuit against a third party such as a property owner or equipment manufacturer. Unlike workers’ comp, a third-party lawsuit requires proof of negligence. However, the victim can potentially claim broader damages such as:
- Past and present medical expenses
- Full lost wages
- Loss of future earning capacity
- Pain and suffering
- Emotional distress
- Permanent disability or disfigurement
- Loss of enjoyment of life
- Out-of-pocket expenses related to the injury
- Loss of consortium (in eligible cases)
If the victim dies from their injuries, the personal representative of the victim’s estate could potentially seek wrongful death damages on behalf of estate distributees such as the surviving spouse, children, or parents. Potential compensation may include funeral and burial expenses, the victim’s final medical bills, loss of the victim’s income, and loss of services.
How Our New York Excavation Accident Attorney Can Help
If you’ve been injured in an excavation accident in New York, including Nassau, Suffolk, Queens, Bronx, Kings/Brooklyn and New York counties, our experienced lawyers can help you. When you retain us to represent you, we will:
- Review the facts of your case
- Identify the responsible parties
- Plan a case strategy
- Calculate a fair value of your damages
- File all necessary claims and paperwork
- Aggressively seek financial compensation on your behalf
We are dedicated to helping victims and their families recover the compensation they need to recover. To learn more about how we serve accident victims, read our past results. Although past results do not guarantee future outcomes, they do speak to the level of client commitment we bring to each case we represent.
Contact Our New York & Long Island Excavation Accident Attorneys
Excavation workers deserve to work in safe environments free from unreasonable hazards. But if you or a loved one has been injured, it’s time to get serious about your legal rights. That’s where Dell & Dean, PLLC comes in. To learn more or to schedule a free initial consultation, give us a call or complete our online contact form today.
Frequently Asked Questions
How can an attorney help me obtain and preserve relevant evidence?
Depending on the facts of your excavation accident, relevant evidence might include photos and videos of the accident scene, eyewitness statements, inspection records, OSHA reports, prior accidents and complaints, safety records, contracts, medical records, income information, and expert witness opinions.
However, it’s important that evidence is preserved right away so it’s not lost. Excavation sites can be altered, trenches can be filled, equipment can be moved, and details can be forgotten. An experienced New York excavation accident lawyer can help you preserve evidence by:
- Sending evidence-preservation letters to parties in possession of evidence
- Conduct a site inspection, often with the assistance of expert witnesses
- Promptly request sensitive evidence, like video footage, that can quickly be deleted
- Identify and obtain construction and safety records
- Use formal discovery to obtain relevant evidence
- Request court orders, as necessary, to prevent evidence from getting lost
How are OSHA regulations relevant to these cases?
Although an OSHA regulation violation is not itself proof of liability, it can be relevant to your case. For example, evidence that someone violated a regulation could help establish causation. It may also serve as evidence of negligence or it could strengthen other evidence.
A knowledgeable attorney will understand which OSHA regulations are applicable in your case and what to do with evidence of a violation. In that way, your attorney can use all available evidence to strengthen your claim.
What is the deadline to file a New York excavation accident lawsuit?
Victims generally have three years from the date of an accident to file a lawsuit. A two-year deadline, known as the statute of limitations, applies in general to wrongful death lawsuits. If the defendant is a government entity, a notice of claim may need to be served within 90 days of the accident and a lawsuit may need to be filed no later than one year and 90 days from the accident.
These deadlines can vary based on the claim and the defendant. Different deadlines apply to workers’ comp claims. Speak with an attorney at your earliest convenience to preserve your legal rights.